9.2 Assessing Intrinsic Value:
Key Concepts
The
AEG Model starts with capitalized earnings (which are earnings
earned in perpetuity) and then further adjusts this value for
added value from forecast earnings growth.
Three new
terms underlying this approach and which are:
·
Normal Earnings,
·
Cum-dividend Earnings, and
·
Abnormal Earnings Growth.
We will
develop these terms next.
Normal Earnings
A firm’s
normal earnings are defined as earnings that arise from earnings
growth at one plus the investors’ required rate of return:
Normal
Earningst = (1 + Cost of Equity Capital) *
Comprehensive Earningst-1
Recall that Comprehensive Earnings was a term introduced in the
Residual Income Valuation Model which for convenience we
summarize again:
Comprehensive Income
The
accounting concept of “Comprehensive Income” measures the change
in Stockholders’ Equity not involving the stockholders.
It is related to the traditional Accounting Income except
that in practice not all items pass through the accounting
income statement.
For example, the major items being foreign currency
translation adjustments, derivative accounting and certain
pension liability adjustments.
Dividends, Treasury stock acquisitions and any new stock
issues are not included because these involve the stockholders.
Cum-Dividend Earnings
Cum-Dividend Earnings are defined as:
Cum-dividend earnings = Comprehensive Earnings + Cost of Equity
Capital*Accounting Dividendt-1
This in turn permits us to define Abnormal Earnings Growth, as
follows.
Abnormal Earnings Growth
This concept is designed to capture the value added from
anticipated earnings growth.
In a two stage growth model of intrinsic value, the
growth behavior for stage 1 we have referred to as “abnormal
growth.” This is
because during stage 1, growth behavior is permitted to exceed
economy wide growth bounds.
The interval of time covered by stage 1 is often assumed
by analysts to be in the range of 5-7 years, but the exact
length is subject to economic considerations.
For example, a software firm may only have 2-years of
large growth before competition sets in, whereas a monopolist
who is protected by strong barriers to entry such as patents may
have 10-years. As a
result, analysts must take into account these economic
considerations when deciding how many years to define stage 1
over plus the assumed growth rate for this period of time.
Stage 2 immediately follows stage 1.
For a going concern, stage 2 is assumed to last forever
for mathematical convenience and lets us calculate present
values as perpetuities.
As a practical note, because the required rate of return
is positive, discounting eliminates the “forever part” by
applying smaller and smaller present value weightings to cash
inflows further out in time.
In this stage growth is referred to as normal and it is
bound from above by economy wide growth.
The abnormal earnings growth refers to earnings growth over time
and is defined each year (time = t) to be the difference between
dividend protected earnings and earnings that grow at the
required rate of return.
This is defined as follows:
Abnormal Earnings Growtht =
Cum-Dividend Earningst – Normal Earningst
And Cum-Dividend Earnings are defined as:
Cum-dividend earnings =
Comprehensive Earnings + Cost of Equity
Capital*Accounting Dividendt-1
Note: Both Abnormal
Earnings Growth and Residual Earnings approaches to valuation
are based upon the clean surplus accounting using “Comprehensive
Income” which attempts to measure the total of all operating and
financial events that have changed the shareholders’ equity over
the period.
To project residual earnings into the future the second
important input for this concept is assessed growth behavior of
earnings. This
allows earnings to be projected out over time by growing at the
assessed growth rates.
Under these projections, if abnormal earnings growth is
expected to be positive over time then intrinsic value will
exceed the capitalized earnings and vice-versa.
Concept 3 (Cost of Capital):
The cost of capital is the investors’
required rate of return from the investment.
This is the discount rate used to compute the present
value of future residual earnings per share.
It is equivalently referred to as the stock’s
cost of equity capital.
Next we will apply the above concepts to assess the intrinsic value of IBM.